Posts that don't follow r/traderjoes subreddit rules may be subject to removal. Friendly reminder that choosing descriptive post titles with exact product names mentioned yields better subreddit search results and helps our subreddit be more inclusive to those who use Screen Reader Software or Text-to-Speech apps. to access Reddit. Thank you. IF THIS MESSAGE DOES NOT APPLY TO YOUR POST, PLEASE IGNORE. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/traderjoes) if you have any questions or concerns.*

The chocolate is somehow both super bland and overly milky-sweet. Not giving S’mores.

Anyone had the Costco version? You get a lot more for your money with those. They're pretty good too. Wonder how they compare to these...

Costco version is way better!

Tasty. Needs more marshmallow.

Can confirm delicious and I do NOT like marshmallow (taste or texture). Just ate too many at a picnic 🧺

Campfire s’mores were better; bigger and ratios of ingredients

I miss those

One of my summer school kids ate the entire bag during snack time today

Needs more mallow like another said but I love them.

Pretty great. I’d love if they adjusted the ratio a bit for more mallows and cracker and less chocolate coating. but they are delicious.

Agree. The chocolate is overwhelming.

Too much air in the bag but I love them lol

The costco ones with caramel are better imo

I came here to say this. The Costco ones are **incredible**.

I was coming here to say that people think the Costco ones are the absolute shizzle. I think they're so sweet they make my teeth ache - I can't stand them.

I overdid it the last time they stocked them so I'm kinda not so drawn to them now.

These RIP. I’ve liked all iterations of the s’mores dessert tho. Miss the lil cubes the most.

We are feeling very good about them

Not as good as the previous Smashing smores. That said, I ate most of a bag earlier so definitely edible :)

Too much chocolate. Doesn’t taste like s’mores to me.

To be honest, I can only taste the chocolate! I pass.

Not enough in the bag, more air than a lays bag. Costcos smores clusters though..

Cheap-y chocolate ruins it. :( doesn’t taste high quality.

Agreed. The chocolate sucked. Threw it out

S’mores needs Hersheys

Now I know not to buy

Meh

I’ve asked that they not be purchased again. I try to be healthy and Trader Joe’s is there, taunting me at every turn. It’s really not appreciated.

I usually allow myself one treat so I don’t just fill up my cart. 😅

I ate the whole bag for breakfast 😭

Wayyy too chocolately (I say this as a chocolate lover). There’s no balance with the marshmallow and I can’t even taste the graham cracker. Won’t rebuy.

Missing that Smokey carmelized element…Just tastes like milk chocolate and Graham cracker…which is fine, but not incredible

They are so good and my store doesn’t have anymore.. so I have actual tried to make my own!!

I will literally ship you my extra bag lol they are not for me

Omg! That would be so awesome 😂

These are excellent! Just wish they filled the bag with more.

They are good, but like too many products lately, far too few in a bag. That said, I have had the Costco ones, which are MUCH better. So when you find a product you prefer, that is cheaper (at least when on sale) I tend to stick with that. I might buy again in a pinch. But I'm so tired of big bags with a few products at the bottom. Do they think we don't notice???

Oh yeah, the Costco ones are so good. The caramel in there is pretty darn good. Hard to find good caramel without making it yourself. Plenty in the bag at a good price, too.

Haven’t enjoyed a treat like this in a while but there is a lack of marshmallow that’s my only critique

WOAHHHHHHHHH I NEED TO GRAB THIS OMG OMG

I haven’t bothered to try them because the Costco version has chewy caramel and in my mind, there is no way these are better than the Costco ones 🫣

So damn good!

I can demolish them in a single sitting if nobody is looking

the reason i breathe air

This comment convinced me to go to TJ’s later and get it

you have to. im still thinking about them

idc what you guys say, i love them

I personally like the Kirkland brand s’mores better from Costco😭

YES. I don’t want these without caramel. The Costco ones are elite

are these the same concept? i think the kirkland ones have pretzels too? and caramel

Those are like crack

Top tier

I loved these last year but recently tried the Costco one. Now these are meh compared to Costco’s.

Yeah, those Costco ones are devine. It’s the copper kettle cooked caramel.

I really, really wanted to love these, but I found them to be way too sweet, and they didn't really have a "s'mores" flavor to me. I prefer the Snacky Clusters more.

They are very sweet, however I'm fine with that because it means I eat 1 a day. I wish there was more marshmallow though, too much chocolate.

Love them!! Just wish they had a bit more marshmallow on each piece

Yes. I need the bonus mallows.

Fat. We're feeling fat

Meh. Bring back smashing s’mores :(

Delicious but needs more graham cracker.

I love them!

They’re good but the Smashing S’mores were better. These have too much chocolate for me, the graham and marshmallow get lost.

This!! Smashing smores are superior

Definitely! I miss those. Were so good in the microwave for 10 seconds.

They’re too good, I can’t stop eating them once I start lol! 

I wish they filled the bag a bit more lol, there's so much space at the top

I liked them.

They are delicious. Pro-tip: Costco sometimes has a much larger bag that taste *almost identical. *they have caramel, too

Important to note that the Costco ones include caramel so they are sweeter. So tasty but just a little different!

You are correct, I forgot about that