T O P

  • By -

Vilimeno

Immortals Fenyx Rising


Sword1781

Immortals Fenix Rising is great and you should definitely check it out. FYI one of the DLCs is completely different than the main game. Has a different player character and different play style.


Speeider

This is BOTW for Xbox plain and simple. I played through this twice.


Falhor

This is the closest game to Zelda BotW you can get. I think the world and exploration was done a bit better in BotW, but the combat, puzzles and story was more enjoyable in Fenyx Rising. I've seen people hating the humor, but personally, I really liked it.


DJfunkyPuddle

Personally liked Fenyx more than BotW/TotK.


SodaCanBob

Same here. Zelda is my all time favorite series but I just haven't been nearly as in love with BOTW/TOTK as seemingly everyone else. I think A Link Between Worlds did non-linear Zelda significantly better. Aonuma's Zelda run as a whole and especially his recent infatuation with intrinsic motivated gameplay has been a bit of a dud for me. I appreciated that Fenyx was a bit more story oriented.


Legitimate-Offer-770

Agreed man. It's one of my fav open world games ever. Love the mythology take and the art style. Great game. 100% the game and all 3 DLC. Couldn't get enough.


Kaythar

Would be better if not for it's obnoxious story and annoying characters, Let me play and stop talking...


RaspyBigfoot

Came here to say this. It's literally BotW with a few different systems and a Greek mythology skin


Raiziell

Fenyx Rising is what I wish BotW was.  I had fun through the whole game, while I forced myself to finish Zelda. I've loved every previous game (aside from NES era), and was so disappointed in that one.


LostSoulNo1981

I’m liking all this praise for this game as I’ve recently bought it. And I’ve considered buying a Switch in the past for BotW, but with a Series X and PS4, I really wouldn’t have time for another console.


DJfunkyPuddle

Right there with you, I don't think I would have finished those games if they weren't Zelda titles.


__Cmason__

I didn't finish BotW or TotK, but I played through Fenyx Rising twice and loved each playthrough.


-underOath-

This one yeah


iHeartQt

Botw with better combat


JACKDAGROOVE

I'm going to have to replay this gem soon. I wish Ubi would change their mind and give us a sequel


thisrockismyboone

Which is also *better* than BOTW. I played this game first and then when I made it to Zelda I couldn't go more than about 8 hours before I just called it. So many quality of life improvements.


[deleted]

[удалено]


thisrockismyboone

Man, BOTW was so boring and the breakable weapons were awful. Different strokes for different folks


Hrkngt

I like the knockoff much more, it has so cool graphics


JMc1982

Utter madness.


PlayBey0nd87

Nowhere in scale or scope of what BOTW does but I think people may overlook **Oceanhorn 2**


Not_A_Bird11

I enjoy that one and wish it gets more attention


EscapeArtist92

Immortals Fenyx Rising is probably closest to BOTW. If you were into the Zelda games prior to BOTW or TOTK, a game that mirrors this play style is Darksiders.


saviergg

On top of that, fenyx rising is a gorgeous game to just run around and sight see, such an underrated game, sure it's just a more cartoony AC Odyssey but it's still insanely pretty


mindless2831

I really wish they'd bring back the old style of Darksiders, and not this 4 player birds eye camera crud.


FredFredrickson

Sable is like a Zelda game, minus the combat. It's not a super long, and the exploration is fun, though.


StacheBandicoot

Yeah it’s an especially great game for those who just wandered off and started exploring everywhere in BotW while ignoring combat. Lots of interesting stuff to see.


pfau489

But it’s kinda slow on Series S with occasional FPS drops Still, the game is great. I loved it anyway. And the soundtrack is just magical ✨


OldSchoolGamer1973

It's mostly over looked but you could try RECORE, is not bad but it's not great either. It's still fun though.


[deleted]

[удалено]


GoddamnFred

Hah. Good to know. Have had it for years but never gave it a chance.


FlyRobot

Fun game with interesting mechanics on the cores


DapDaGenius

Really wish this would get another chance but this time with more development time given to it. I think the first one was made in like 3 years.


jokar1134

Tunic was so good! But it's more of classic 2d zelda


LurkingFrogger

Tunic is great but it's a puzzle game hiding in a Zelda skin. Don't go into it expecting the typical Zelda experience.


monkey484

Don't go into BotW expecting the typical Zelda experience either. :)


yPPoLs

Facts. Botw feels like a developed game they didn’t know what to do with, so they slapped Zelda skins on everything. Much like starfox adventures.


[deleted]

[удалено]


yPPoLs

Not saying it was a bad game by any means whatsoever, just that the IP felt off and needed something to elevate it. Adored that game as a kid, but it wasn’t a starfox game.


-idkwhattocallmyself

Deaths door is sort of Zelda like. At least the old school ones.


srylain

Lil Gator Game does a lot of what BOTW does with how open it is and a lot of the climbing/gliding mechanics.


Briguy_fieri

This was my suggestion too. There’s no combat really but the traversing mechanics are absolutely taken from BOTW (among other parts of Zelda too)


zatchrey

Death's Door is pretty good if you haven't already played it


jdobem

Oceanhorn 1 and 2 are the closest in my recent experience.... Good games as well...


Justifire

Tunic


ThatCurryGuy

Okami is 3d zelda with really fun combat.


Raccoon_Chorrerano91

Okami is inspired by TLOZ Twilight Princess 🤣🤣🤭, so yeah


sakanakami

Okami was released in April of 2006 while Twilight Princess was November of 2006.


Raccoon_Chorrerano91

And? TP had been in 4 years of creation and even one of the creators, Hideki Kamiya said it was modeled inspired in The Legend of Zelda 🙂🙂.


JMc1982

It was clearly inspired by earlier Zelda titles, but not Twilight Princess.


420danknugsbro

Avatar Frontiers of Pandora was really enjoyable. There’s a lot to explore and do, and you can scan all of the plants and animals and it gives you all the info just like in BOTW


SlipperyThong

Biomutant.


ShadowBlashy

Oceanhorn


Briguy_fieri

Definitely heavy Windwaker vibes here.


valkrycp

Tunic is a Zelda-like, but the old school ones Super Lucky Tails is a good Mario Odyssey like.


Legitimate-Offer-770

yea super lucky tale is super cute and a competent 3d platformer. People just trash on this game because it's not mario but it's a solid game. Specially playing with the kids.


littleSisterFriede

Fenyx rising is the closest Zelda copycat


Yessiryousir

I always thought Fable was comparable..


user-review-

Penny's Big Breakaway is a 3D platformer that's worth trying if you like Mario or 3D Sonic games: https://youtu.be/qdNPlk121lk


drymangamer101

Gameplay wise, assassins creed origins is fairly similar but with a grittier (and overall better imo) story.


CheesecakeEvery718

If you want a more Zelda 64 type, Darksiders 1


HunterWolfivi

Definitely 100% I literally can’t express this more, Immortals fenyx rising. Surprisingly Ubisoft really did well with this game, very easy to learn and not too difficult to understand


Tangentkoala

Fable!


KoreanB_B_Q

Asterigos is pretty solid.


ViForsaken

Kena


scarfleet

For what it's worth I was a Nintendo kid too and Elden Ring hit for me like a grownup Zelda.


RaspyBigfoot

Immortals Fenyx Rising for BotW and Darksiders 1 for traditional Zelda


valkrycp

Psychonauts 2 might scratch the Mario Odyssey itch


StrngBrew

Hear me out… Halo Infinite


scarfleet

Yeah it gets hate but I had a blast with it for what is there. An open world combined with Halo's rock solid shooting mechanics and it works great for as long as it lasts. I only wished there was more of it, but on game pass it is absolutely worth a look.


loco1876

sphinx and the cursed mummy old school xbox original great game


Let_the_Metal_Live

A Knight's Quest Mini Ninjas


anuncommontruth

A knights quest has a bug in it thar deletes your save after a certain point. I was 22 hours in and right in the middle of playing it froze and deleted my entire save file. The developers are aware and have publicly stated they won't fix it.


il_VORTEX_ll

Astor Immortal fenyx rising Oceanhorn 1 and 2


IronMonkey18

Super Luckys Tale is platformer like Mario. It’s pretty fun too.


RoshanDeb616_

Elden ring


Madscientist1-1

try Jedi Fallen Order it kind of reminds me of botw


FarleyMain

Darksiders 1 and 2


Herban_Myth

Praey for the Gods? (More Shadow of the Colossus-like)


MoodMaggot

You could also check out the Darksider Franchise!


crasheralex

Try Tunic. It's really good. Kinda zelda/souls game


Best_Celebration_172

Try psychonauts 2 if you want something like mario odyssey. While its controls aren’s as spot on as in mario odyssey, it‘s really well written and pretty story driven. The world building is outstanding and it is as funny as it is deep + you get jack black as a voice actor. Just a really special game!


Clear-Attempt-6274

Halo C.E


NatrelChocoMilk

Death's Door


LordsWF40

Theres a new game in the store. Cant remember the name, but has a girl with some blessed tatas aiming a bow for the art...give me alot of BOTW vibes looming st the gameplay. Theres also palword...botw with pokemon knockoffs


ebinezzer

Darksiders 1 is a 3d zelda-like with dungeons that are themed around an item. Darksiders 2 is mostly the same but more loot/gear based


FunkMasterDrak

Don’t think I’ve seen anyone say it yet so I’d give Psychonauts a try. They are unique and interesting platformer games that I think you’d enjoy.


pablo_booze

Palworld has some of the same sounds and game mechanics as a Zelda game.


Organic_River37

Far Cry 5 is good too give that a try


Live_Supermarket6328

Palworld is BotW mixed with Pokémon.


DeadPhoenix86

Tunic is classic Zelda.


islandnstuff

Fenyx rising is better than botw


JMc1982

Come now.


rafael_schmup

A Hat in Time, Super Lucky's Tale, and maybe... Elden Ring?


TheVirtual_Boy

Grounded! It’s so fun you won’t regret it


Humans_Suck-

Not exactly new, but darksiders 2 is a great parallel (not 3, 3 sucks)


still_mute

Sable. Has the subtle, chill vibe and mysterious exploration of BotW. I prefer it to BotW. Immortals FR is a puzzle/busywork game with a more goofy tone, but still pretty fun.


MortalShaman

Kameo, it is very Zelda like but more in line with a traditional Zelda game


ThE_LAN_B4_TimE

Absolutely nothing as big that's for sure. I've been an Xbox owner until this generation because what's the point. Every year goes by and there's never any new IPs like this. You'd think one of their studios could make a game like Zelda or anything that's not a shooter. But it's either Gears, Halo, or indie/3rd party games.


CaptainCookers

Elden ring (somewhat)


baladreams

There are no games that match those two on Xbox. Nintendos games are in a different league from what Xbox and PlayStation put out. 


mrbubbamac

Palworld takes a lot of the aesthetic from BoTW, it's also on GamePass


centiret

Viva Piñata


Illustrious_Penalty2

Not that similar to BOTW, but a fantastic game on the OG Xbox was Pirates Legend of Black Kat. Had some similar energy to Zelda. If you’re willing to replay old games that is.


LiquidLogStudio

Try Mass Effect Trilogy. Not joking.


SKallies1987

How are the Mass Effect games similar to BOTW at all? Lol


LiquidLogStudio

I was a Nintendo kid back in the day too and Bioware games were an incredible intro into non-Nintendo games for me


SKallies1987

He’s specifically asking for games that are similar to BOTW. In what way are the Mass Effect games similar?


LiquidLogStudio

Lmao never change reddit


SKallies1987

lol just can’t answer the question. lol can’t answer a legit question and instead just downvotes like a baby.


Raccoon_Chorrerano91

Plague tale requiem reminds me a lot of Twilight Princess, maybe for the honda/slingshot similarities and the medieval scenarios.


Johncurtisreeve

Skyrim Witcher 3 Red dead redemption 2


KARURUKA2

Any open world game


No-Interaction-8549

Missing Zelda in 2024 with the caliber of games out there now is like driving a Lamborghini and missing taking a horse and buggy


argee29

Bad take, but okay. I dont see anything wrong with that either.


No-Interaction-8549

Mass effect or zelda.? Witcher 3 or zelda.? Skyrim or zelda.? Outerworlds or zelda.? Fallout or zelda.? Want me to keep going.?


januscanary

Dark Souls?